Skip to main content
European Commission logo
European Nuclear Safety Regulators Group

Topical Peer Reviews

Under the Nuclear Safety Directive, a topical peer review (TPR) is an EU-wide review conducted by experts from Member States on a selected nuclear safety topic. Its purpose is to share experience, identify best practices and common challenges, and recommend follow-up actions to address any weaknesses.

TPRs enable EU and other participating countries to collaboratively examine a technically significant aspect of nuclear safety that is currently relevant. These reviews, held at least every six years, promote continuous improvement in nuclear safety through cooperation among regulatory authorities and licensees across different countries. The process draws on the approach used for the nuclear stress tests conducted after the Fukushima accident in Japan in 2011. It is designed to be transparent and structured in three phases: national assessments, peer review, and follow-up implementation.

The first TPR (2016-2018) focused on ‘ageing management of nuclear reactors’, while the second TPR (2021-2025) addressed ‘fire-protection at nuclear installations’. Discussions on the topic of the third TPR (2027-2031) are now underway.

A key feature of TPRs is their transparency and openness towards stakeholders at both European and international levels. Stakeholder meetings are held, and participants have the opportunity to comment on process documents and submit written questions to countries regarding the information in their national reports.

 

ENSREG has a subgroup dedicated to the Topical Peer Reviews. Find more information on the group here.

 

Topical peer reviews I and II 

TPR I: Ageing Management of Nuclear Power Plants and Research Reactors (2016-2018)

The first topical peer review (TPR I), conducted between 2016 and 2018, focused on ageing management in nuclear power plants and research reactors. This review was the most significant safety-related exercise after the post-Fukushima stress tests in Europe. It involved 19 participating countries (16 EU member states, plus Norway, Ukraine, and Switzerland). 

Why Ageing Management? 

The topic was selected due to the ageing profile of European nuclear power plants and the potential for long-term operation. ENSREG led the review, with technical support from the Western European Nuclear Regulators’ Association (WENRA).  

TPR I Review process 

The structured assessment included: 

  • National assessment reports – Drafted by nuclear safety regulators based on licensees’ self-assessments.
  • Desktop peer review – Conducted by nominated experts from participating countries.
  • Stakeholder engagement – Over 2 300 questions submitted by peer reviewers, experts and civil society.
  • One-week workshop (May 2018) – Attended by ~140 experts, to discuss findings, questions and responses. 

 

Outcomes and Follow-Up 

In October 2018, ENSREG approved the final report on the review and country specific findings (Press release). National action plans were then developed to address the results. The entire review process was conducted with full transparency, ensuring open access to documentation and active stakeholder engagement throughout. 

 

Key Challenges Identified 

The review highlighted four major challenges where European-level action could enhance ageing management: 

  1. Overall ageing management programmes
  2. Concealed pipework
  3. Reactor pressure vessels
  4. Concrete containment structures 

 

National Action Plan Measures 

Participating countries committed to measures such as: 

  • Formalising ageing management definitions for research reactors.
  • Updating in-service inspections of civil structures in line with international standards.
  • Enhancing monitoring, testing, and inspections for concealed pipework.
  • Ensuring cable performance under extreme accident conditions.
  • Defining performance indicators for ageing management.
  • Applying ageing management practices to new constructions. 

     

TPR II: Fire Protection at Nuclear Installations (2021-2025) 

The second Topical Peer Review (TPR II), again led by ENSREG with WENRA’s technical support, focused on fire protection. 22 countries participated (18 EU member states, plus Switzerland, Türkiye, Ukraine and the UK). 

 

TPR II Review Process 

The review followed a structured approach: 

  • National Assessment Reports – Based on licensees’ self-assessments.
  • Desktop peer review and site visits – Conducted by experts, including inspections of selected research reactors.
  • Stakeholder engagement – Questions and comments phase.
  • Two workshops –To discuss thematic findings, responses, and country reviews. 

 

Why Fire Protection?  

Fire was chosen as a priority topic because: 

• It poses a significant risk to nuclear installations. 

• There is extensive experience with fire-related incidents. 

• Practical improvements are feasible. 

• It is a technologically neutral field. 

• It had not been covered in previous post-Fukushima assessments. 

 

Key Challenges Identified 

The review identified: 

  • Three EU-level challenges and four good practices,
  • 54 areas for improvement and 38 examples of good performance at the national level.  

Participating countries are actively addressing these challenges and areas for improvement. 

 

Main findings 

The primary focus areas include: 

• Use of operational experience feedback, 

• Management of fire loads and ignition sources, 

• Methodologies for fire safety analysis, 

• Strategies for fire detector installation and failure management. 

 

National Action Plan Measures 

Follow up of the TPR II findings can be found in the participating countries’ national action plans (NAcPs), and in the ENSREG action plan currently being developed. 

 

For further details, see the Final report and country reviews and national action plans (NAcPs).

 

TPR III: What will be the topic?

The third Topical Peer Review (TPR III) will start in 2027. 

The topic of the third Topical Peer Review will be decided by the European Nuclear Safety Regulators Group (ENSREG) in December 2026. The following topics have been proposed, based on an analysis of their safety significance, regulatory relevance, and technical merits: 

  • Climate change and natural hazards
  • Operating experience (OPEX)
  • Grid disturbance

The summary below provides stakeholders with an overview of each topic proposed. Feedback is welcomed through the designated EU Survey form. The survey is open until 13 November 2026.

Candidate topic: Climate change and natural hazards

Nuclear installations are designed to cope with natural hazards, and their safety is periodically reviewed. However, climate change can exacerbate natural hazards such as wildfires or extreme weather phenomena such as droughts, and these could occur more frequently or simultaneously with other external hazards that further challenge the nuclear safety of installations. Climate change is a long-term and evolving issue that is relevant for both existing installations, and the design of new installations.

Focusing on nuclear safety impacts, the peer review would aim to share information on how the effects of the changing climate are considered in the safety of nuclear installations. It would review regulatory and licensee approaches, identify good practices and areas for improvement, and share lessons from climate-related events that challenge nuclear safety. It would look at how new scientific knowledge is used in hazard assessments and how the results can be used to identify additional measures to maintain adequate protection of nuclear installations throughout their lifetime.

Candidate topic: Operating experience (OPEX)

Operating experience (OPEX) involves the systematic collection and analysis of information from the operation of nuclear installations, with the aim of identifying lessons learned, preventing the recurrence of events and continuously improving nuclear safety. OPEX is a key driver of continuous improvement, and can reveal potential failures of equipment or safety functions, common issues, weaknesses in design, maintenance, procedures, human factors or organisational arrangements and the need for corrective actions. The topic is relevant not only for licensees but also for regulators. It can evaluate how regulators set reporting rules, assess licensee programmes, apply operational experience to inspections, and improve their own regulatory processes.

The peer review would look at the practices and tools for collection, storage and analysis of data from operating experience, allowing to better understand how OPEX feedback is implemented by licensees, review its effectiveness, and the regulatory practices for its oversight. It can help improve the efficiency of existing practices both nationally and at the international level and provide opportunities to learn from each other.

Candidate topic: Grid disturbance

Electricity grid disturbances could affect the safety of nuclear installations. Electricity grid disturbances can be caused by unexpected, abnormal variations in the voltage, frequency, or electrical current flowing through a power grid. The impact of such disturbances on the stability of the electricity grid and possible effects on electricity supply sources such as nuclear power plants are becoming increasingly important, as the European power system undergoes a transformation through increased renewable energy integration, expanded energy storage and increased interconnections, alongside possible natural and human-induced hazards.

Reliable connection to the external grid and a stable off-site power supply are particularly essential for nuclear power plants. A peer review would allow to share experience on types of grid disturbance, compare regulatory and oversight approaches, identify the safety-relevant effects on nuclear installations and discuss measures to manage and reduce the risks. This topic would support specific safety improvements by identifying the consequences of grid disturbances, deriving lessons learned, good practices and recommendations.

What are your comments on the three candidates topics? Reply to this survey and tell us more by 13 November 2026.